Sony WF-1000XM3
Contents
Setup
- Firmware: 2.1.0
- App: 6.1.4.
I didn’t think the Sony WF-1000XM3 sounded that great out of the box. I changed out the tips for some Comply and adjusted the EQ settings in the app to get maximum performance. I’ve also turned off “adaptive sound” and “DSEE HX” and left “Ambient Sound” on. For some reason, the sound is tighter and more detailed when active noise canceling on.
I still need to do some tweaking with the ambient mode set to on. Just tailor it to whatever sounds good to you.
Sound
There’s a rosiness and “beauty” to the sound of these true wireless earphones. Aside from some of the strongest bass I’ve heard, it has fantastic transparency and detail. The sound is clean, crystal clear, and overall very balanced. In fact, it has some of the most forward and insightful mids. And it does so while promoting a more relaxed and smooth sound.
The Sony WF-1000XM3 is cozier than it is brilliant – almost dreamy. Focus and imaging are soft and not super crisp or refined. Cymbal crashes sound a bit rolled-off and trumpets don’t have the proper textures – but there’s something to be said about the easy listening experience. It almost sounds “vintage.”
The soundstage is modest and there isn’t a lot of brilliance or speed. It’s not snappy sounding earbud. The tone is more of a pink-brown rather than a grey or a golden hue. It’s not a tonal hue I hear often. It’s not really warm, or cold…or dark. Otherwise, timbre is decent. Delineation is pretty poor – so sometimes the sound is mushy and grouped. You’ll get a random helping of soul here and there – but it has more of a glaze and chill sound. It’s more liquid and soft than it is tangible and tactile. As far as control, articulation is good.
Overall the WF-1000XM3 is smooth, detailed, punchy, coherent, analog-ish. It has enough “truth.” In a way, this earphone is a crowd-pleaser. It doesn’t do one thing terribly enough to distract you.
Comparisons
- Jaybird Vista: The Jaybird has better focus, timbre, tone, and shape. There are more mold and color to the music. It’s also more assertive. The Sony sounds a little too soft and mushy. Everything just sounds overly cloudy around the edges. Sony wraps around your head more but has looser articulation.
- Samsung Galaxy Buds: These two have very different signatures. The Sony is smooth, gradated, and warmer while Samsung is leaner, more detailed, and treble present. The Sony also has a broader sound.
- Master & Dynamic MV07 GO: The Sony has much better bass and larger image than the M&D. The M&D is slightly warmer but far more resolving. The Sony is cleaner and more open whereas the M&D is meatier, more dynamic, and more exciting.
- Sennheiser Momentum True Wireless: The Sony is just a better performing earphone. In comparison, it’s more transparent and naturally toned.
- Soundcore Liberty 2 Pro: The Soundcore isn’t nearly as smooth but has much higher tonal quality.
- Edifier TWS NB: The Edifier has a cozier and more “live” atmosphere and is tonally denser.
- Soundcore Liberty Neo (Original): The Soundcore actually sounds more natural, but doesn’t have the lifelike resolution of the Sony. The Sony has a fatter, less focused sound, but more analog and has more “cushion.” There are no stringy, hard edges to the sound – and it lacks a bit of shine. It is easier to listen to but isn’t “accurate.” The Sony has a much bigger more “glamoured” sound – but the Soundcore is more believable. It wants to make everything easier to listen to. FWIW, the Soundcore sounds closer to the reference system.
- 1More ANC: 1More has more dynamics, bass, and truer tonal saturations. But is a bit messier in its articulation. In ANC mode #2, the bass seems to overpower and bend the rest of the space. There’s something really jarring about the 1More. The 1More sounds right and wrong. There’s a natural color but the coherence and image are confusing. The Sony just sounds “good” without any glaring faults. Although timbre isn’t as accurate, the music just glides more naturally with the Sony. The 1More is tighter and more focused, the Sony more forward and “fat.”
- 1More Stylish: Imaging is actually clearer on the Stylish, but it sounds much muddier in comparison. The Stylish is also much flatter sounding with fewer tonal variations. The Stylish still sounds more coherent, however.
- Jabra Elite 75t: The Jabra is grainer and sharper but more vibrant with a punchier bass. It’s also more tactile, especially in regards to stringed instruments. The Sony is more analog and lifelike in its smoothness. Jabra has crispier and more accurate treble. The Sony’s treble isn’t very accurate, but instead a bit soft. The Jabra sounds more piecewise and disconnected in imaging. Sony is more coherent and “organic” sounding. Bass is more pronounced on the Jabra.
Side Notes
- One of the easiest earbuds to pair to my Pixel 3.
- Turning ambient sound control on seems to warm up the sound – but fuzzies up everything. In a way, it smooths it out a bit making the sound more analog.
Who should buy it?
The Sony WF-1000XM3 is a “safe bet.” It has enough tunability to get it to sound how you’d like. However, its treble and ability to delineated will be limited. It’s more of a smoother, more graceful sounding, high-resolution true wireless earbud. It won’t be the most tangible or dynamic – but it’ll be easy to listen to.
Very nice article and I tend to agree with most if not all your assessments. I own most of these headphones and am a headphone addict. Clearly sound and headphones reviews are very subjective. I appreciate all your efforts here! Well done!
Thank you for your support, David. Gonna keep pushin’ forward!
Try huawei freebuds 3, they could be the best, they shock me how good r they.
I think this is probably the best audio review comparison for a buyer that I’ve ever read. No. Not probably. Actually it is the best. That’s because you’ve written the good AND the bad about every product. Never said one item is better absolutely. Explained what you liked and why, which is VERY important as I might like something that you don’t. Though most importantly, you compared the items at the end with both the good and bad points in a comparative way. This grouping of descriptions and comparisons actually makes your ranking list not very useful and confusing, BUT! makes the whole review useful and informative and can help a person decide which product THEY would like. I still like my old Wf-1000x buds but was looking for something, probably by now, better. By reading your reviews I might actually rank the new Sony buds as number one (though I’d have to hear them of course). The beauty of your reviews is that I can actually get some idea of what I WOULD actually like and what to try first. Awesome writing and well thought out.
Thank you, Mark. It’s interesting because some days, I don’t mind having something further down the ranking list for the “unique” qualities it presents. It’s sometimes about the mood or about the appreciation of a certain type of sound. Although I prefer a more natural sound, I sometimes still enjoy the “fantasy” that some of these headphones provide. It amazes me how much information is capture by the microphone – which I don’t think even the performers or engineers knew about. I did perform this experiment for my own record keeping. Figured it’ll give me a good reference point for things I hear in the future. Everyone enjoys music differently and I’m glad I was able to help.
I’m going to doubt this product is better than the Sony it was compared to.
Great review. I have settled on 3 sets of earbuds for my everyday use.
1. Soundcore Liberty 2 Pro – For home use. I agree wholeheartedly about your remarks regarding these earbuds, and now Soundcore has added a 7 band EQ allowing you to custom eq them, so that’s fantastic. Their relatively weak IPX rating and substandard call performance keeps them from being my “go to” phones, but when I am at home, these are the ones I pick up.
2. Sony WF-1000XM3 – Although not as good sounding as the L2P, The sublime ANC of these buds makes these my default travel gear, edging out my Bose QC35ii over the ear cans. The sound isolation on these is actually better than my Bose. And the portability of them is self evident. No IPX rating makes them strictly for plane trips and similar use cases. Definitely a niche product, but once you travel with ANC, there’s no going back.
3. Soundcre Liberty Air 2 – These are my default “out and about” phones. The slight trade off in sound quality is more than offset by the smaller case, stronger water resistance and call quality. The soundcore app allows you to EQ them quite a bit, so I can get good sound even in environments that are not conducive to it.
Have you tried the lypertek tevi?
I’ve bought a pair before. I don’t think it’s worth comparing to the ones up here. Not super great in my opinion
I have been looking for exactly such an analysis. I have been looking for a TWS for exactly the same purpose as yours except that call quality is a semi-important factor. I mostly use iFi xDSD for Bluetooth receiver with JVC FD0X or Sony MD855. Anyway, it would be interesting if you could rate Galaxy bud live that has an open design with a bass duct and 12mm driver. My interest in it for its call quality and I heard it is better than galaxy bud+. Thank you.
Thank you so much for your review man!!!! I tried many earbuds and the M&D MW07 GO is a clear win on sound quality in my opinion! So detailed, precise, layered, immersive and just beautiful sound in all genres. I can hear many new sounds in the same old songs and music that I listen over and over again. I have been a Bose fan for so long but M&D will be my new faith on sound quality. Thank you for such a professional and honest review!!! Appreciate it!!!
My pleasure 🙂
This is has become my go to reference source – the care and attention to detail that went into this is amazing; so, Thank You! I have always struggled with pure ranking lists and have been skeptical of kickback bias. I have been on a quest to find the highest call/mic quality without sacrificing my music preferences. This has served as a good cross-reference. I was generally happy with the Momentum TW’s call-wise; however, was never a big fan of how music sounded through them (although I really wanted them to be good). That combined with the flaws (“volume min / volume min / volume min”) drove me away. I am on the phone all day for work and like to listen to music in between. I’m currently using Jabra 75t’s and they seem pretty good for both purposes – the extra bass doesn’t bother me too much but heavier music tends to sound a little muddled to my liking.
Has anyone else had good experiences with TWS with the right call quality / musicality balance? Always open to opinions and suggestions.
Thanks!
You had me with how you arranged and photographed the boxes.
I was wondering if you had an earbud recommendation for heavier music? I was leaning towards the Liberty 2 Pro or MW07 GO’s based on your reviews but I figured I’d check to see if there was something I was missing. Thanks!
Not sure what you mean by heavier music? Bass?
More on the metal and punk spectrum of genres. I know EQ’s on these genres are tuned higher on the high and low ends but leave the mids largely unchanged.
Thank you for sharing this very fine review.
Have a wonderful new year!
Good job. I look forward to more of your interesting observations.
Wow, this review is fantastic. I still have of course some questions, as it’s difficult to understand what do you mean by “colour”, “gray”, “darker”. Do you have a link to know more about these sound terms ?
I am looking right now a pair of wireless earbuds for walking in the street and make sports mainly. I really don’t care about the outside noise, and some others functionnality. I just whant to listen to music 🙂
This is what I really liked in your review. This is crazy how it is difficult to find a such audio quality based review.
I like the warm and open feeling of the sound. I was a fan of the senheiser X100. which is light, simple, semi-opened (I think this is the key of this “warm” – I an not sure about the term – sound I like. I am a definitely analog guy 🙂
So I am hesitating right now with the MW07GO, the powerbeats PRO, bose sound sport free (for which you were positively surprised. There are also the newer sport earbuds).
I am listening the music for enjoying it. I make music myself. I have a good hear, I hear a lot of details. But I am afraid of a too precise earbuds that could be annoying after a while or could hurt ears specially if the high are to crispy. So let’s say I want to enjoy the music more than I want to analyse music, I like the idea of smoothness. I like 90s rock. Foo flighters. I like mediation music. I like rap. Soundtracks music, definitely. An important point is that my source are not specially super quality records. Could be important. Warm, Space and Detailled, Opened (I would like to avoid a feeling of chlostrophoby) could be the most important adjectives I guess in what I am looking for.
With this description could you recommand me one or two ? (in my list or not of course)
I take you a coffee right now 🙂 thanks you so much for this work
An amateur of anaolog music and photography.
warm to me is that brown, fireplace, golden color to the sound. Grey is a darker sound outside of neutral (colorless). Basically just shades of gray to black. A colder tone is icy and blue.
the Liberty 2 Pro might be fatiguing but has the best tone. The Sennheiser Momentum True Wireless 2 in High-end tuning mode might be what you’re looking for. It’s not very warm but strikes a good balance.
Great review. I modified Piano EQ as Jay suggested and added Comply tips (and removed both rubber bands). I am so much enjoying the Liberty 2 pro. Thanks Jay!!
Paul
”Unfortunately, I can’t customize the “Piano” EQ and save it as my own. I would take the highs down a tad and boost the 200-300 Hz region. Reason being that these earphones have this ever-present coarseness in the mids. It’s kind of edgy, hissy, screechy, and resembles static at times. These adjustments would hopefully close the micro-caps and hopefully smooth over the grain”.
EQ: piano
Hz / Gain
100Hz / 0
200Hz / 3
400Hz / 3
800Hz / 2
1.6kHz / 4
3.2kHz / 5
6.4kHz / 3
12.8kHz / 4
EQ: piano (slightly modified)
Hz / Gain
100Hz / -1
200Hz / 2
400Hz / 2
800Hz / 2
1.6kHz / 4
3.2kHz / 5
6.4kHz / 3
12.8kHz / 4
Thank you for sharing this useful information about Wireless earbuds. Great article. I’m looking forward to reading your next essay. Thank you once more!